Composite decking has risen in popularity in recent years, compelling all potential deck builders to carefully weigh the benefits and drawbacks of the material vs traditional wood construction. Several aspects influence the final decision in the composite decking vs. wood decking comparison, including:
- Upkeep and durability
- Appearance Costs
- Sustainability and the Environment
Depending on a customer’s financial situation and design preferences, either solution could be the victor. But, in order to comprehend the long-term worth of wood vs. composite deck materials, consider the advantages and disadvantages of each.
The Case for Composite Decking
What makes composite decking such an excellent option? To begin with, once installed, composite decks require relatively little maintenance. This advantage is especially obvious when comparing composite vs. wood decks.
Upkeep and durability
Composite decks just require semi-annual cleaning – a simple soap and water scrape is generally sufficient. The advantage of composite is that it does not require sanding, sealing, or staining. Those who live in particularly severe areas (prone to heavy rain or snow, for example) may need to clean their deck more frequently. This is true regardless of the material used to construct their deck.
What is the lifespan of composite decking?
With the exception of extreme circumstances such as fire damage, high-end composite decking should last for decades. Composite materials come with outstanding warranties because of their longevity, making them a superior long-term investment.
Costs
Composite materials have greater initial costs than wood materials, which sometimes causes consumers to be hesitant. However, a little research might help clear up any pricing concerns.
Cost comparisons demonstrate that installing composite decking is more expensive than using pressure-treated wood because the specialized material necessitates a higher cost. Composites, on the other hand, have near-zero maintenance expenses.
Appearance
Great aesthetics are usually determined by the material’s quality and the originality of the building and design. In that vein, composite decking provides more design variation than wood decking, with more hues, tones, and patterns available.
The distinction between the two materials is based on authenticity, personal preference, and continual customization. Composite materials do not alter over time, although wood can be stained and painted. This gives you a wonderful look that will last for years, but the trade-off is that you won’t be able to switch to a new color or stain in a few years if your tastes change.
Environmental Sustainability and Impact
Composite decking is the clear favorite among environmentally aware buyers. Built from recycled materials such as plastic film and reclaimed sawdust, this alternative ensures a lower carbon impact for the buyer.
Aside from the material distinction, composite decking is naturally more durable. Consumers will use fewer resources and chemicals in deck care because there is less maintenance and cleaning necessary.
The Case for Wood Decking
Even while some composite items are scientifically advanced, wood enthusiasts can’t help but pine for the classics. Let’s look at what makes wood a viable option for your outdoor deck.
Upkeep and durability
Wood is naturally durable, but it requires significantly more upkeep than composite materials. To keep a perfect deck, wood deck owners must be more cautious and proactive than composite deck owners, due to environmental issues such as water and insect damage, as well as higher material breakability.
How long will a wood deck last?
Every one to two years, wood decks should be sanded, cleaned, stained, painted, and sealed. The wood and the deck as a whole would disintegrate if not treated, but a well-cared-for deck may endure 15 years or more.
Moisture and insect damage are possible
Other concerns with wood that persist are environmental elements that lead to wear and strain. Because of its inherent construction, wood is more prone to these issues than composite, making it vulnerable to any of the following if not treated:
- Splintering Warping Cracking
- Mold and mildew growth
- Rotting and deterioration
- Pests and insects
Insect and insect damage is especially problematic if your wood deck has suffered water damage. Certain softwoods require regular chemical treatment to weatherproof and repel bugs, which adds to the continuing cost depending on the type you choose.
Is it worthwhile to invest in wood decking?
A decent deck could last a decade or two if money is no object and you’re devoted to wood and the labor required to maintain it. However, for long-term savings on your deck, wood simply cannot compete with the cost durability of composite decking. The following items will be included in the overall maintenance costs:
- Coating and staining
- Power washing
- Increasing water resistance and restoring water damage
- Insect damage repair
- Breakage repair
- Appearance
Wood offers a more naturally real feel than many types of composite decking, which is important to many deck owners. More expensive hardwoods, such as redwood or bamboo, offer a rustic, high-quality look and feel that most composite decks cannot match.
Environmental Sustainability and Impact
If you want an economical upfront choice with pressure-treated lumber or are committed to the look of natural wood, wood may be the way to go. However, if you want an eco-friendly solution that requires no maintenance and has a higher lifetime value, composite decking is the material for you.
In addition to the effects of deforestation, wood decks nearly invariably require extensive treatment with various external chemicals on a regular basis. Varnishes, oils, and other materials help to maintain deck durability, but they might have a negative impact on your backyard or local environment over time.
The Comparison between Composite and Wood Decking
In the end, the choice between composite and wood decking comes down to personal preference. Those determined to make wood decks work can find a robust, affordable upfront solution with pressure-treated lumber, which allows greater long-term customizing options with dyes and colors.
However, for those willing to pay more upfront in exchange for long-term durability and cheaper maintenance costs. Composite decking provides an eco-friendly option for deck builders that wood simply cannot match.
